November 20, 2026

BENGALURU EXPRESS

Truth Triumphs

Honour the sacrifice! Do not tax the pain!

Spread the love

GUEST COLUMN : Dr N Prabhudev

Bengaluru Express
Bengaluru, Sep. 8:
The concepts of honor and sacrifice have served as the bedrock of human character and value system.Indian Army soldiers don’t fear death; they inspire us to live and die bravely.”“A soldier’s uniform is stitched with honour, courage, and sacrifice!

As Indian citizens, it’s our duty to know our heroes—their stories, their sacrifices. The Indian Army goes beyond a mere salary; soldiers serve for a cause, not just a paycheck. They stand ready to give their lives, often unnoticed by many who are unaware of the true cost of their freedom.

A soldier is defined by commitment.
Soldiers who die in the face of enemy action are braver than literally anyone else alive. They function with utter knowledge that the breaths they draw could be their last.
He serves the nation without asking what he will receive in return. He does not negotiate with duty. He does not calculate the price of patriotism. He simply stands where the nation needs him to stand.
And then, one day, there is a terror combat – he loses a limb. He survives. He is fitted with an artificial limb. The nation grants him a disability pension—not as charity, not as a favour, but as a modest recognition of a sacrifice that can never truly be compensated.
He returns home with his head held high.
But somewhere behind a desk in a manthralay , a Babu – reasonably well off but with a weird sense of pleasure and a touch of sadism pens a strange idea in the file – The disability pension is “income”. Therefore, it must be taxed.
And what is even more disturbing is that the idea travels upward through the hierarchy, receiving approval from senior officers who apparently see a number in a file rather than a limb lost in the service of the Republic.
This is where bureaucracy loses its soul.
A soldier does not lose a limb as an investment.
He does not surrender his body for a financial return.
He gives because duty demands it.The pension is not the price of his sacrifice.It is an obligation of a grateful nation towards one of its wounded defenders.
To tax the compensation for a limb lost in the defence of the country is to commit a profound moral absurdity: to treat sacrifice as a source of taxable income.
A government may tax earnings, tax profits, tax wealth. But surely, it must never put a tax on the consequences of a soldier’s sacrifice.The artificial limb replaces what the soldier lost in the service of the country. The pension helps sustain the life altered by that loss.
The artificial limb and the Disability pension – neither replaces the limb. Neither restores the years of service. Neither compensates the human being completely.
So let us say it plainly:
The soldier’s sacrifice is not income.
His disability is not an earning opportunity.
His pension is not a privilege.
And the limb he sacrificed for the nation is certainly not taxable. The bureaucracy may be technically correct but the nation becomes morally bankrupt

Just because someone can endure pain does not mean they should be expected to endure it forever. The soldier’s sacrifice is noble.
True sacrifice comes from love, conviction, responsibility or purpose. But when society begins to expect sacrifice it slowly turns into exploitation.

Some of the strongest people in our lives do not complain—not because they feel no pain, but because they have learned to carry it without making it someone else’s burden. Their silence should not make their sacrifice invisible. Their resilience should not make their suffering irrelevant.

Let us be grateful! Gratitude is not merely saying thank you.Let us understand the value and the patriotism behind the sacrifice !
It is remembering the years behind the moment, the tears behind the smile, the compromises behind the achievement and the dreams that were quietly placed on the altar of responsibility.

That sacrifice is noble does not make its pain pleasurable.
The fact that someone chose it does not mean it was easy. JN
The fact that they endured it does not mean it did not hurt.
And the fact that they never complained does not reduce the pain.
Do not make the mistake of asking them to sacrifice again simply because they sacrificed once before.
For the deepest measure of gratitude is not how beautifully we speak about someone’s sacrifice—but how carefully we ensure that their sacrifice was not in vain.


Spread the love